1. Which creation story sounds the most plausible?
- The gods fashion man unsuccessfully first from mud, then from wood, and finally succeed with corn and corn meal
- A god fashions the first humans from clay mixed with the flesh and blood of a deceased god
- A god fashions the first human from clay, and another god breathes life into it
- A god fashions the first man from the dust of the earth, and then fashions the first woman from a rib of the man
2. Which flood story sounds most likely?
- A great flood lasting generations is abated with the assistance of various supernatural creatures
- A great flood lasting several years is survived by one man on a giant boat containing all animals and plants
- A great flood lasting several days is survived by one man, one woman, and a multitude of babies on a massive canoe
- A great flood lasting forty days is survived by one family on a boat containing sets of every animal
3. Which miracle most likely occurred?
- A man multiplies the yield of date trees to help someone pay off their father’s debts
- A man produces fire from one side of his body and water from the other
- A man cures his immobilized leg and arm by sprinkling them with water
- A man feeds a crowd of thousands using only five loaves of bread and two fish
4. Which is the most believable afterlife destination?
- Islands of fertile soil, bountiful produce, and fair winds
- A massive hall with a roof made from golden shields and an endless supply of mead
- A paradise of palaces filled with sensual delights, including delicious food and drink
- A city with golden streets, gates of pearl, jasper walls, and jeweled foundations
Why should we believe the Jewish/Christian account of creation and not the Mayan, Babylonian, or Greek versions? Why should we believe the Jewish/Christian flood narrative and not the Chinese, Hindu, or Squamish accounts? Why should we accept the miracles of Jesus and not those of Muhammad, Buddha, or Sathya Sai Baba? Why aim for the Christian heaven and not the Greek, Norse, or Muslim variants?
Growing up Christian, I was raised hearing certain stories in church and naively accepting them. This stores didn’t seem strange until I stepped back and viewed Christianity in the context of other world religions. When you realize your faith has its fanciful tales, and other faiths have their fanciful tales, you start wondering which is actually true – or if none are true.